Often, after a player coming from another program (rec program, slow pitch, Class C level or other select program) makes a STARS team, the player and their family will tell us about the myths they’d believed about the STARS up until that point. Whether they’d heard it from someone else or just conjured it in their own mind, they’ve come up with some interesting myths.
One of the most prominent myths is that the player must dedicate their lives to softball. This is absolutely not true! Many STARS players play multiple sports from the youngest team through the 18U team. Many of the girls in high school play for the STARS, their high school softball team, and another sport. We recognize that dedication to softball makes great players, but we also recognize that girls who play multiple sports are more athletic and less prone to injury. During the fall, the schedule only includes one practice a week (on the weekends) and play 2-3 tournaments. After the fall season ends, the girls take November through the beginning of January off (we recognize the value of this rest period!). In the winter, the girls attend one (sometimes two) practices a week on the weekend and have the option of attending open gyms to work on their skills. They are not required to attend, but speaking for the 14U team, many of my girls enjoy the open gyms – the individualized attention and focus on whatever skill they want to work on. As winter ends and spring begins, the girls turn it up with 2 practices a week and tournaments on the weekends. Contrary to popular belief, most teams play approximately 12 tournaments (about 3 weekends per month). The STARS program allows for kids to be kids and highly skilled softball players.
Another myth we hear frequently is that it is extremely expensive to play. We heard it costs thousands of dollars. Well, that’s just completely false. Between the registration fees and uniforms (which went down in price this year!), the approximate cost is about $600. Now, this doesn’t include travel which can be a bit pricey, but the STARS do everything they can to keep costs down. We wear the same uniforms for years so the major uniform costs only occur for the first year or so. We pass down some of our uniforms. As the STARS is a true organization, many players have gotten hand-me-down pants from players on older teams who have grown out of theirs. We also do many fundraisers to keep costs down and we find sponsors to help cover the costs. With tournament registration fees at or more than $500/tournament, indoor time expenses, equipment needed, etc., it’s amazing how low we can keep the cost (consider that most teams play 12 tournaments in the summer and 2-3 in the fall!). Note that no one associated with the Maryland Stars is paid — we all are volunteers. Additionally, it’s notable that there has never been a girl chosen for a STARS team that was turned away because she and her parents didn’t have the money (we find a way for her to play).
We’ve also heard that the STARS teams travel so much. For the 10U, 12U, and 14U age groups, most teams will have 1-2 overnight tournaments (requiring hotel stays). One of these is typically a national tournament. The younger (10U-14U) teams mostly play locally. For example, this year, the 12U STARS team will play an ASA Eastern national tournament which will require much less time and financial commitment from the parents. The older teams, 16U and 18U, will travel more, but this is important at this age for the girls who want to play softball in college and need exposure to the college coaches for recruiting purposes.
One myth I always find surprising is that at the 10U age group, the pitchers spend most of their time walking the batters and it’s no fun for anyone. This just isn’t true. It may have been true once in the area, before fastpitch bloomed here. But now, the 10U pitchers can throw strikes and the game is interesting and exciting for the girls, fans, and coaches. In fact, 10U pitchers get better every year I see them with the girls beginning to pitch younger and younger.
The playing time myth is also getting dispelled here. Our belief in the STARS program is that if a kid is good enough to make the team, they are good enough to play in the games. Playing time is based on ability, but also on commitment to improvement, attendance at team functions (practices, fundraisers, etc.) and attitude. No girl who plays on a STARS team sits on the bench even 50% of the time and all players sit out at times as they can learn a lot by watching.
Playing time goes hand-in-hand with another myth of the STARS: We are a win-at-all-costs program. Of all of the myths, this is the one I disagree with most. Success in the STARS program is not based on your record. Success is based on the development of the players and their improvement. I constantly tell my team (ad nauseam even) that I don’t expect perfection. I want to see improvement every week. I want to see them “moving in the direction” of excellence, not perfection. If we won every game all season, I would know that I had not challenged my team enough. It’s not about winning and losing, it’s about developing and challenging ourselves. It’s about fun. When I reminisce about playing my playing days, I don’t think about winning or losing, I think about the memories I made out there. I miss how it felt. Ask any STARS player who played and eventually aged out, and they’ll say the same thing. The STARS program stresses individual and team development and also fun. Because softball is game and if it’s not fun, what’s the point in doing it?
There are some other myths about the type of player the STARS want. Some say it’s big, strong kids and other people will say we want fast, little ones. There is no type of player that is right for the STARS. Big, medium, or small, every girl who plays in the STARS program brings their own special skills and personality and that’s what we’re looking for.
I’ve also heard that the STARS only get their players from other A-level fastpitch teams. This is impossible! There are just not enough players that are already at the A-level to do that. The STARS find players from all over – slow pitch leagues, instructional fastpitch, even baseball. In the younger age groups (10U-14U), it’s common to have a player from one of those other leagues/levels of play/or other sports. STARS coaches look for things that go beyond experience – potential, attitude, fit for the team, etc. Just because a girl doesn’t have the experience playing on a high level fastpitch team, doesn’t mean we aren’t interested in her. We recognize that there’s much more to a player than her experience (because everyone was inexperienced at some point!).
And finally, the myth that never ceases to surprise me: Softball comes before education. I’m not sure why anyone would ever think we or any program might believe that. We understand the reality for most softball players is that they won’t make a career out of softball. It’s almost impossible to live on the salary paid to professional players and only a few players get endorsements. Most players can only hope to play softball while they’re in college and enjoy it while it lasts. The point is that education is more important because it affects the girl’s future for the rest of her life. Furthermore, the regulating bodies of college athletics require the players to maintain a certain GPA or the player will be ineligible. The STARS coaches frequently check report cards to ensure the players are maintaining high GPAs. I know as the 14U coach, it is so important to me that my team continues to thrive academically and athletically, but if I had to choose, academics will win every time.
I doubt I’ll ever know where these myths come from, but I do know that they aren’t true. Consider these myths BUSTED.